

Being both a casual Joy Division fan and a relatively new and somewhat uneducated Bob Dylan fan, I am not perhaps the most suited person to review the two (somewhat) current biopics Control and I’m Not There. At first glance you may place these two films in the same sort of box in your head. Before I saw them I did the same thing. Not so now. Having been waiting to see Control for some months (after missing it at the cinema and being too early for rental) I was super-excited to watch it on the internet with friends this new year’s eve. I was also bitterly disappointed. I’m Not There provided the total antithesis. While Corbijn’s film was moving, beautifully shot and featuring a stunning performance from Samantha Morton as the unappreciated and emotionally tortured Deborah Curtis, there was no subtlety. Everything was spelt out so that it quickly became a narrative going through the motions without a hint of originality. That is probably a little harsh, but the plot was so brutally hammered into the film that it felt like there was nothing under the surface. As I say, I’m Not There was completely opposite to this. For a start, the story itself was never told. With Bob Dylan never being mentioned by name and six actors taking on his role simplicity went out the window. It felt like you had to think about things; take in the surroundings of each scene, mentally capture each character to find out later how they joined on to another, try desperately to work out the date. Much more rewarding than Control’s linear narrative. It also contained the most stunning performance from Cate Blanchett as Dylan post ’66 (where he was named Jude. Get it?). Since then I’ve watched the documentary No Direction Home which caused me to sit with my mouth open! Cate Blanchett was even better than I’d thought at the time! Every movement and utterance was spot on. As well as narrative, this film also fucked with the chronology, making it hard to follow, rewarding to understand, and cooler than ever when two of the “Dylans” met at the end. Glorious!
To be honest, one of the best things about each of the films was the soundtrack. Mmmmmmmmmmmmmmm.
(Sorry for rambling, that is all).



